Gen X at 40

Canada's Favorite Blog

Comments

Ben (The Tiger in Exile) -

As I've said before, he's an infuriating sort of leader to watch...

Alan -

I tend to keep my infuriating relationships short ones.

'nee -

I would like him to dance a little jig.

I think Harper should have a half hour daily show on the CBC where he interviews a prominent civil servant (to get to know them, like) and then perhaps does a little dance, or perhaps sings a cover from a quality band.

That, I would like. I never get what I like, though. Too bad.

Flea -

It isn't only Alberta's oil and gas revenue that is on the silver tray of bon-bons. The unconstitutional oil giveaway to Newfoundland should soon make Newfies as self-reliant and self-congratulatory as Albertans. And hey, why share any of that accidental oil wealth with the rest of us when Ontario can continue to pick up the tab. Sickening. With each passing day I find new degrees of astonishment that anybody can call this government conservative.

ALan -

I understood NS and NL were getting rid of the clawback on oil and gas for payback of past equalization so that they did not get double penalized. I did not realize that all oil and gas wealth is being removed from the equalization so that Alberta's fluke of riches is now not being considered wealth needing to be shared.

Gordo -

Bloody hell. Why shouldn't Alberta have to share the wealth? I didn't know it had been removed from the equation, either.

Chris Taylor -

I'm okay with Alberta not sharing the wealth; it's not like I share bonuses or investment income with my neighbours. If every other province wants a bigger piece of the pie, let them get competitive and earn it.

Alan -

Yes, let's all get competitive and create geological formations! Let's also make sure the Federal government transferred the right to the formation without value in return in the 1920s!

Chris Taylor -

C'mon Alan, you know better. Title might be the only reasonable sticking point. Life never deals out an equal hand to everyone, and equality of outcomes is hardly something that can be mandated countrywide.

Why should Alberta (or anyplace else) shell out more due to its particular windfall? Why shouldn't Ontario shell out more because our economic miracle is renewable vs. Alberta's temporary, diminishing windfall?

Alan -

Why should Canada be turned into the unfederation it never was by social and economic engineers? Is this one country? When did conservatism and loyalty to the nation as a nation separate? I know it has but when did money and wealth become the basis for a separatist movement. And according to some fluff I watched on US television news this week, Alberta's pool of glop is 200 years supply. If they do not share and, say, anyone to the south invade, ought we the rest just point the way? Why wouldn't we? Disloyalists. Pig dogs.

Chris Taylor -

I would imagine that your study of Whiggery would make the reasons fairly clear. It's hardly a case of money-grubbing and wealth-mongering so much as the ability to determine, in large part, how that money is spent. Rightly or wrongly Alberta considers the money her own, and adopting an "Ottawa knows best" stance (the traditional attitude of Central Canada, one might argue) is hardly endearing or persuasive to the West.

Alan -

By characterizing the nation as a part of the nation, Albertan has fallen into their own trap of complaint and are destined to always be unhappy despite their blessings. It is exactly wealth-mongering and nothing more. Happy to take when it was needed - NS's money for the railway, Federal rights to oil and gas for free - but when they are overcome by surplus, get the source of the goodies off the ledger. Consider how Harper's plan apparently leave's Ontario's mining wealth (merely solidified minerals, you know) on the equalization ledger. No logic. Just taking care on one's own squeeky wheel.

Post a Comment: Silent Steve

Email addresses are not displayed with your comment and will not be shared.
Allowed tags are: <em>, <strong>, <code> and <a href="url">. All other tags will be displayed as plain text.