Gen X at 40

Canada's Favorite Blog

Comments

Chris Taylor -

Or he could take his nice suit and chuck himself into a small island's volcano (The Big Woo?) on behalf of the orange-soda-drinking islanders, like the title character in <i>Joe vs. the Volcano</i>.

Alan -

omG! He is actually living the script of a 1980s B movie. Wow.

Gordo -

Isn't he officially a candidate for mental health treatment now? You're gonna die != go nuts with your money. Sheesh. The Americanization of the Western world continues.

cm -

He admits that it's his own fault he has no money left. No way could he win that court case. Right?

Gordo -

Ye Gods, one can hope.

Matt Fletcher -

Certainly it would seem ridiculous for the hospital/doctors to have to pay for Mr. Brandrick's spending spree. The hospital cannot be liable for all of the specific actions Mr. B took because of their incorrect diagnosis. If that were the case the hospital might feasibly be liable for every improper action and cost Mr. B incurred after his diagnosis. Theoretically he could blame every bad action and decision on the improper diagnosis - lost my wallet in March, it was the hospital's fault - forgot my anniversary, it was the hospital's fault etc.

The claims of Mr. B and the way the Globe frames the story does make the suit seem ridiculous. However, it does seem like a suit for some type of damages on the basis of such an erroneous diagnosis would not be totally unreasonable.

Jay Currie -

I like the fact that the hospital maintains in the last para that "The hospital has said that while it sympathizes with Mr. Brandrick, a review of his case showed no different diagnosis would have been made."

The old, "we were wrong then and we'd be just as wrong now" defence.

Alan -

There is a claim called "wrongful life" in which misdiagnoses related to severely disabled children are missed. I understand that the claim is not for general damages but only the extra costs of special needs of the child. Those costs are foreseeable. If the authors of <i>Joe vs. the Volcano</i> could foresee the reactions, should not the hospital?

portland -

he was living large for a year, enjoying himself like it was his last day on earth, having fun, everything right on edge. maybe he should pay the hospital.

Post a Comment: Group Project: At Least He Has His Health

Email addresses are not displayed with your comment and will not be shared.
Allowed tags are: <em>, <strong>, <code> and <a href="url">. All other tags will be displayed as plain text.