Amid the gnashing of Tory teeth over their own decision to turf Garth Turner has popped up the delicious idea that our former Finance Minister will now become Canada's first member of Parliament for the Greens. Sure it came from brother Doug, usually not a hot national news source despite his location, but it is an attractive idea.
- First, Garth blogs (though as ST notes, he may well also edit.) Tories do not blog - Monty had to quit blogging when he got to sit at the big table. Reasonable policy for an unknown medium run by hobbyists as far as I see but Garth needed to express himself. You can't fight for the little guy and hide your light under a bush, you know.
- Second, Garth may find the idea of protecting the environment through "intensity" standards a joke. That may not make him particularized enough to be a Green - as it seems to include most of Quebec again now - but I suspect all Greens fall into that larger category.
- Third, Garth is a showman. Love it or hate it, he loves the camera and the camera has certain feelings for him. He was a TV investment guru in the 1990s after he was Minister of Finance for, what, a month or so and he found a way to fill an hour before the reruns of Xena on the CHCH Hamilton mid-Saturday afternoon TV schedule.

Comments
Hans - October 19, 2006 10:55 am
Hers's a bandwagon I can jump on and start shouting about! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth!
Chris Taylor - October 19, 2006 11:29 am
I am okay with Garth joining any party as he does not really seem to understand the notion that, in the federal legislature, politics is largely a team sport. He is the John Nunziata of this age.
Gordo - October 19, 2006 11:35 am
Shortly after being elected new Green Party leader, Elizabeth May predicted that the Greens would have more influence/voice in Parliament very soon. Could this be, in fact, a very well-laid trap that the PMO has blundered in to? Hmmmmm.
Hans - October 19, 2006 11:35 am
Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth!
Chris Taylor - October 19, 2006 11:40 am
I should add that I think Garth was right to criticise the CPC over the Fortier appointment, just as Nunziata was right to criticise the Liberals for failing to repeal the GST as promised. Where they fall down is in the ability to effectively influence their peers; lacking any such capacity they are restricted to public tantrum-throwing and this is what generates disciplinary actions.
Flea - October 19, 2006 12:27 pm
G<i>arth</i>.
E<i>arth</i>.
Just saying.
Gordo - October 19, 2006 12:50 pm
A meeting is being scheduled! http://www.cbc.ca/canada/story/2006/10/19/turner-reax.html
Alan - October 19, 2006 1:06 pm
F<i>lea</i>.<p>Walter Brim<i>ley</i>.<p>Me say, too.
Ben (The Tiger) - October 19, 2006 2:13 pm
Gordo --
Thereby splitting the vote on the left <i>three</i> ways?!
Whose trap, whose stumble?
Gordo - October 19, 2006 2:31 pm
Bah. A trap laid by May for Harper. Turner's been publicly uncomfortable with the Tories for months. Who better for May to target for a seat?
I've said it for several years that the ONLY way for the Greens to garner influence in the house is have sitting MPs. That way the government can steal their poicies an dmake them their own.
Flea - October 19, 2006 2:36 pm
Wilford Brimley is not to be trifled with.
gorthos - October 19, 2006 2:58 pm
Alan
Gowan
aha!
Chris Taylor - October 19, 2006 3:10 pm
So does Al have "A Criminal Mind", or is he merely a "Strange Animal"...?
Hans - October 19, 2006 3:24 pm
The Green Party is on the left? How so? Left of what? Centre? Ayn Rand?
Hans - October 19, 2006 3:25 pm
Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth!
Alan - October 19, 2006 3:26 pm
The personal ability to cite Gowan song titles in banter is an excellent thing.
Gordo - October 19, 2006 3:27 pm
The Greens are left in that the environment isn't a Conservative issue. Ever. Other than raping it. They're fiscally very conservative.
Hans - October 19, 2006 3:52 pm
So the Conservatives could actually be left of the Greens on certain fiscal issues? Just like those leftists to not really know where they stand, which is to say, where conservatives want to pigeonhole them.
Don - October 19, 2006 4:41 pm
My favourite Garth post:
http://www.garth.ca/weblog/2006/02/12/the-meeting/#comments
It was typical media tactics and it made me think of a comment Brian Mulroney said one day. The Tories were about to bring in the GST. The country was in media haos. Protests were everywhere. The polls were a disaster.
Mulroney stood erect and impeccable at the podium in the caucus room. Outside, just beyond the double doors that sound-roofed the room, a phalanx of media waited, convinced some MPs would buckle under all the pressure, walk up to the forest of microphones, criticize their besieged leader and open the floodgates of party dissention. Just what any good reporter would want, of course. Blood.
And Mulroney said: “If you want to be a media hero, just walk out those doors right now, go down the hall and do it. I guarantee you’ll be on the front page of every newspaper tomorrow and the lead item on the CBC tonight. Go ahead. I’ll still be here. But if you want to be a hero for Canada, then you will stand by me.” He stared into the eyes of everyone in that room. Anyone who harboured the remotest thought of mutiny felt it evaporate under his gaze. Leadership.
Being a media hero is easy, fun and has instant rewards, I thought. Belinda Stronach. Carolyn Parrish. Scott Brison. Getting on the front page of the Globe and Mail and the National Post is a breeze. Just say what they want.
Of course, I told the reporter Harper is our leader. We have only one leader at a time. The leader leads – it’s his job. A candidate’s highest job is to get elected.
Garth - media hero.
Alan - October 19, 2006 5:08 pm
I am witnessing a straw man. Garth does nothing in particular this week to cause himself getting the boot, someone somewhere pulls the trigger and boots him out of the party, the news turns to Garth (coincidentally on the day of the nutty science environment policy announcement) and all of a sudden that makes Garth a media whore. Garth uses his blog to communicate with his constituents as he always has, does nothing new and <i>he</i> somehow become the manipulator. Nutty. <p>By the way, has anyone asked where the good and honest Stephen Taylor (I mean that serious as he is one of the best political bloggers in Canada) got his original copy of the smoking gun? Has he (the good, above-average, single but lonely, struggling blogger) the personal resources to monitor Garth's site and pull hour by hour edits from five months ago for the GOTCHA moment? Or was this a party central resource that stuck this away for an opportune moment. Either way it is legitimate as it was in the public space but, as with the shadowy process that saw Mr. Turner removed from the party, we also are dealing with an unclear process as to how this "evil Garth" moment was arrived upon this week.
Alan - October 19, 2006 5:37 pm
Garth spoke today.<p>By the way, I have a hard time calling him Mr. Turner as Mr. Turner in my mind is the past PM. Garth he is.
Chris Taylor - October 19, 2006 5:50 pm
As an academic exercise I can hardly wait to see how many shots Mr. Turner (The Rt. Hon. Mr. Turner would be the former PM, natch) gets to take at Ms. Elizabeth May before the notional Green caucus votes him off the island.
Scott - October 19, 2006 11:29 pm
If he does sit as the lone Green party member, who knows, he could have as much influence on the Canadian political scene as did Deborah Grey in'89. A fiscally responsible and rapidly growing Green party would definitely have an effect on the two traditional parties in the House. Could they end up being the tent that houses the majority of disenchanted moderate tories? I never thought so initially, but with Garth possibly joining them in the House, anything is possible.
Scott - October 19, 2006 11:42 pm
Oooops. I see that all that was already covered by Alan et al. I guess like all blogging flunkies, I buy my keyboards by the barrel. ;-)
Hans - October 20, 2006 11:03 am
Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth! Go Green Garth!