Gen X at 40

Canada's Favorite Blog

Comments

Arthur -

But if the second party decides to use the concept but not be technically compatible, it will be a weak standard.

Winer's 'law' actually reminds me of Microsoft's scare tactics when they claimed that DR-DOS wasn't the 'real DOS': while DR-Dos was actually better. Pot. Kettle. Kettle. Pot.

Alan -

Yes - never mind that is may even, at that point, be a weak "standard", it will be a string application around which a standard - properly an organic event - will grow. Too often "standards" are also just a front for scardy cats.

Arthur -

Too often "standards" are also just a front for scardy cats

Not to mention that the 'DOS standard' is still breaking up people's Windows computers <g>. Maybe Winer forgets hat it's the market that decides where a 'standard' goes?

Alan -

Oligarchs don't like that word "market".

Arthur -

Oligarchs don't like that word "market".

What I would recommend Winer is to just let it go. Take Linus for example and all those other open source developers. Forking is good. Competition is good too. Keeps developers sharp and it eventually forces competitors to work together.

Just let it go.

Alan -

But he does other things well so he should not go away. He can self-promote, come up with schemes to place himself at the forefront of things and let people know who he is.

Arthur -

<p>But he does other things well so he should not go away
</p>
<p>He does, yes: but I didn't say that he should go away. I said that he should let it (the discussions around RSS) go for the sake of RSS itself. For the sake of progress.</p>

Post a Comment: Bizzare Call to Stop Innovating

Email addresses are not displayed with your comment and will not be shared.
Allowed tags are: <em>, <strong>, <code> and <a href="url">. All other tags will be displayed as plain text.