Gen X at 40

Canada's Favorite Blog

Comments

Ikram -

Maissoneuve is far superior to Walrus. Walrus has that slightly pathetic, desparate Toronto-vibe. Self-consciously trying to be 'world-class'. And failing. Maissoneuve is not trying to be anything at all, other than cool and Montrealish. I suppose each captures its city's zeitgeist effectively.

Speaking of geist, Geist, from Vancouver, is also quite good (a literary, rather than general interest, magazine). And the last issue of Toro was a pleasant suprise (though controlled-circulation magazines leave me cold).

Alan -

You have captured what I wanted to say, Ikram. <i>Walrus</i> is the needy Canadian, world-classy and overly eager. <i>maisonneuve</i> barely lifts above the observations of individuals but gets it right: the piece "The Lost Letter of Stephen Leacock" illustrating the joy of a find in a second-hand book with a letter to Leacock with his hand written response is elegant in its lack of need to analyze the note signed "S.L.". It's just the sort of thing that pops up in Montreal once in a while.

Post a Comment: <i>maisonneuve</i>

Email addresses are not displayed with your comment and will not be shared.
Allowed tags are: <em>, <strong>, <code> and <a href="url">. All other tags will be displayed as plain text.