Gen X at 40

Canada's Favorite Blog

Comments

Wayne -

You are obviously too young to have either known about or appreciate the fact that the greatest ever came from Parry Sound, Ontario.

Wayne -

Plus-minus ratio is a better stat.

Alan -

+/- is a team-reflective stat. Check out Bill Root's +25 or so season in the mid-80s.

Wayne -

Hockey is a team sport. Choose your linemates well, and you, too, can have a high points per game ratio. Would you rather play soccer with Pelé, or moi?

Alan -

Right now, if you can run faster than Pele in his late 60s, likely you. But that is not the point. Mario pulled others along with him to make the team. Big Wayner was surrounded in the mid-80s by others who were a little superior to the Pittsburg guys in the early 90s. What we are doing is comparing the excellent which is a mugs game but for my money, Mario was ahead by a nose. I did see Orr but too early in my life to appreciate the fact that just because my older brother was a big Bruins fan was no reason not to believe they were he and the rest of them all worse than my hero Dave Keon.

Ben -

Plus-minus is a horrible stat. A good defensive player can have a horrible -/+ just because he plays against top opposing players all the time. Meanwhile a top line forward can have a nice fat +/- because he plays on a defensive team or in front of a hot goalie and solid defenders. Then you get the powerplay specialists who score 40 points with a man advantage and don't see it reflected in the stat at all. It's complete bunk.

Post a Comment: Captain Mario

Email addresses are not displayed with your comment and will not be shared.
Allowed tags are: <em>, <strong>, <code> and <a href="url">. All other tags will be displayed as plain text.