The darlings of those with inherited wealth and shares in big tobacco have done it again. The Fraser Institute has out done its call for a flat income tax - an idea raised in the late 1800s when children were chained to industrial machinery and consistently rejected by even the most hardened and twisted Tory since. It now has declared that "Public Auto Insurance Causes More Deaths". [Hmmm...have they thought to research a paper on how deregulated private business causes more deaths? Doubt it.]
Anyway, I am not suggesting that [...well, I am not considering whether...] they have the facts wrong on where and why driving deaths occur but the talking head pushed out the door to talk to inordinately present CBC cameras on TV tonight seemed to be indicating that if car insurance rates reflected actual risk, those engaging in higher risk driving would be given pause not to engaging in car totaling traffic accidents if they paid more to a private company [umm...like those that fund the Fraser Institute.] I think what was being said was if my insurance were to be $2400 a year to a private insurer instead of, say, $1800 to a public one, I am going to give myself a good hard look in the mirror and tell me to drive more safely. Well, no doubt a dreary few are that...er... sensible. Then again, if I:
- have bought a $30,000 car on $500 per month payments;
- spend $200.00 a month on gas, oil, car washes and cool rear view mirror baubles; and
- drop $100.00 a month on a second set of winter tires and rims and other odds and ends

Comments
CMax - September 5, 2003 7:58 am
It appears shills are spewing forth from every dark corner. We are supposed to believe that it is our duty to pay for the gambling debts (stock market investments) of the underwriters. In the past, this kind of behavior has been rewarded by such activities as the unbridaled use of the guillotine to remove the powdered wig holders of the wealthy and their cohorts.
More each day we are all being forced to pay more for just about everything we need and want. Those pushing us for all this more would be wise to know there really is a limit to how much gouging we can/will take.
michael le clair - September 5, 2003 12:23 pm
On pei the stats from the Fraser Institutes insurance report would amount to less then 1 additional fatality per year..... that is according to my basic market research and stats 101 understanding .... statisically insignificant.... these guys are only providing PR propaganda for the big vertically integrated corporate insurance companies that with the banks play a driving role in our unbalanced economy.
I favour sociallizing basic social programs like insurance...healthcare.... education...
etc.
Alan - September 10, 2003 10:52 pm
Funny that the Consumers Association of Canada is more worried about how we cannot afford to prop up private corporate auto insurers anymore. Maybe they did not do as well at creative writing as FI staffers.
Alan - November 7, 2003 12:01 pm
Another Fraser report presented largely as news rather than slanted ideolofact.